Manual or Automatic: Which Is Safer?

cars with automatic transmissions

Raise your hand if you’ve heard the phrase “cars with automatic transmissions are safer than cars with manual transmission”.

Visit any online car forum and you will come across people who will passionately either defend or ridicule the aforementioned phrase. So which one is actually better? Let’s find out:

Driving an Automatic Is Less Stressful

Driving an Automatic Is Less Stressful

Driving a manual car is a lot more stressful than driving an automatic. There are so many things you need to worry about (clutch and gear position). In comparison, with automatic cars, all you need to do is just move the gear in a specific position.

Distracted driving is one of the major causes of accidents in United States. In 2016, 3,000 people lost their lives because of it.

There are fewer distractions when you are driving an automatic. The driver’s focus is completely on the road because of which they are less likely to get involved in an accident.

However, people who prefer manual transmission often complain that sometimes people get too comfortable while driving an automatic.

Furthermore, if studies are anything to go by, there is no significant difference in the reaction time of people who drive manual or automatic cars.

With Manual Cars You Have Greater Control

automatic transmission

If you ask someone with extensive driving experience with both manual as well as automatic cars, they’ll tell you that they feel a lot safer when they are driving a car with manual transmission.

They feel that the manual gearbox gives them more control over the vehicle. Some argue that an automated system is not flexible. Think of it this way. You are driving in rain and the roads are slippery. In such situations, it is a lot easier to adjust the speed in manual cars.

Which Ones Should Beginners Go For?

Purists say that young drivers should learn how to drive a manual before they move on to an automatic. However, automatic cars have started replacing their manual counterparts.

This is due to several reasons. For starters, with advances in technology, the fuel efficiency of automatic cars has improved. Plus, young drivers have short attention spans. They struggle with learning the intricacies of manual transmission.

At the end of the day, whichever option you choose, the important thing is to make sure that you drive safe. Sign up for defensive driving. This technique can help you become a better driver. Driving schools like Jacob’s Driving & Traffic School offer defensive driving classes.

We offer driving lessons for beginners as well. You can also enroll in our online courses. Contact us at (602) 297-1000.